Matthew Broderick and Sarah Jessica Parker
Matthew’s squeaky clean image was tested when it was reported that he had an affair with a 25-year-old woman in 2008. A source told Star Magazine (via Fox News) that the actor first met his alleged mistress at a New York City bar and that the two began hooking up at a show business friend’s townhouse. The relationship reportedly continued while SJP was filming Sex and the City: The Movie in Los Angeles, with eyewitnesses claiming to have seen Matthew make visits to the other woman’s apartment building several times late at night. But the couple denied the cheating rumors, and the following year welcomed twin daughters Marion and Tabitha via a surrogate.