It's Justin Bartha!
Justin and Ashley, seen here in 2010, started dating in 2008 — and even sparked rumors of a $1 million wedding in the south of France — but the romance hit the skids in 2011. Justin found TV fame last year with The New Normal, but it was cancelled (heartbreakingly) after only one season. Don't feel too bad for him, though: He's engaged!
Meanwhile, Ashley has a new, fancy businessman boyfriend.