James Van Der Beek as a Chubby Schlub
Dawson Leery, what happened? Don't be fooled, ladies and gents: the '90s icon and Don't Trust the B— in Apt. 23 star isn't actually putting on the pounds — nor does he actually have that unflattering haircut. This Jan. 13 Instagram pic is merely showing off a costume for his upcoming appearance on How I Met Your Mother.