THEN: Christina Schuller, Season 1
On the show, Christina was billed as the preacher’s daughter who was besties with Morgan. Together, the two bragged about being the sole virgins in their group of friends. Christina’s most memorable moment was when she went to New York for Spring Break for an uncomfortable Broadway audition singing the song from A Walk to Remember.
At the end of the first season, Christina mentioned plans to move to L.A. and get an acting agent.