Jonathan Bennett as Aaron Samuels
Since Mean Girls was Jonathan’s breakout role, you’d think there was nowhere to go but up. Unfortunately, his career didn’t exactly take off: He’s done a handful of straight-to-DVD and made-for-TV movies (Van Wilder: Freshman Year, The Dukes of Hazzard: The Beginning, and Elevator Girl with Mean Girls co-star Lacey Chabert), and he’s guest-starred on a few TV shows (Veronica Mars, Smallville).
In 2013, he reunited with Lacey in two more films this year — Slightly Single in L.A. and Anything Is Possible — though neither made a big splash. We're crossing our fingers that the films he's working on now will do a little better. But the good news? He’s still smokin’ hot.