Bethany Joy Lenz: Haley James Scott
Haley James has come a long way since her early days as Lucas Scott’s brainy BFF. Married to Lucas’s half brother (and rival) in the Season 1 finale (when she was a mere junior in high school), Haley James Scott ended the series a mother of two with musical aspirations and lived happily ever after with the love of her life Nathan.
In real life, Bethany is a mother of one. The actress tied the knot with musician Michael Galeotti in December 2005, and they welcomed daughter Maria Rose in February 2011. However, the couple announced their divorce on March 19, 2012. Bethany has since returned to her maiden name and joined Showtime's Dexter in Season 8.