Sarah Michelle Gellar — in 1997 and 2012
Though Sarah Michelle Gellar had plenty of film roles in the '90s, she will forever be known as the completely crush-worthy (and badass) Buffy the Vampire Slayer in the minds of millions of Buffy fan girls and boys. The 35-year-old actress recently made a long-awaited comeback to TV as twins Bridget Kelly and Siobhan Martin on the CW's very short-lived thriller Ringer — die-hard SMG fans are still holding out for a second season, even though the show was cancelled.
SMG's main role these days is as mom to two kids with Freddie Prinze, Jr. (they've been happily married since 2002!). The adorable couple have two adorable children!