While Charlie Hunnam of Sons of Anarchy was an early favorite, Vampire Diaries fans couldn't resist the devilish grin of Ian Somerhalder (Damon Salvatore)! Either that, or you just wanted to see the full picture of Ian with this adorable puppy. Whatever your motivation, 45.98% named Ian the winner!
Honestly, we don't blame you. A sexy vampire and a friend of the animals? That's a swoon and a half!
A close second was Charlie, with 38.51%. Dedicated Bones and Angel fans rallied for David Boreanaz, too — he took third, with 6.18%.
Are you devastated that Charlie or David didn't win the poll? Do you want to turn some disappointing results around? By all means, keep voting!