Nina Dobrev and Jennifer Lawrence are both 20-something actresses with incredible careers, but they have more in common than their ages. The 24-year-old Vampire Diaries star and the 23-year-old Hunger Games fave have a similar fashion sense — especially when it comes to be ravishing in red.

So, in honor of The Hunger Games: Catching Fire hitting screens next week (and Nina always looking red-hot), we’re going to let you decide who is really the “girl on fire" with a Flashback Friday fashion face-off.

Let’s jump back a few years. Before J.Law was a household name, she was a Best Actress Oscar nominee for Winter’s Bone at the 2011 Academy Awards. She went simple with a bright red custom Calvin Klein sleeveless tank dress, showing off her curves in a gorgeous silhouette. She kept her hair equally simple, yet stunning with loose waves, finishing off her look with minimal jewelry and a small metallic clutch.

On the flip side, Nina Dobrev went for a va-va-voom look with a breathtaking Donna Karan dress that showed off her incredible body. All eyes were on the TVD starlet in her mermaid-cut strapless gown that cascaded behind her on the red carpet. While her Neil Lane jewelry was more flashy than Jennifer’s, it complemented the dress and allowed her to really show off her neckline. She also went for wavy hair, but her hairstyle was more Old Hollywood.

If we’re being completely honest, both girls are on fire, lighting up the red carpet time and time again, but who is the No. 1 lady in red? We’ll let you decide — vote in the reaction buttons below!

Alyse Whitney is Assistant Editor at Wetpaint Entertainment. Follow her on Twitter and Google+.