Since The Vampire DiariesNina Dobrev and Ian Somerhalder split, rumors swirl every time one of them hangs out with someone new, and this time, it’s someone from the supernatural/fairy tale world.

On May 29, a sexy Once Upon a Time star tweeted about hanging out with Nina in Atlanta, calling her “m’girl” and referencing their fun, hilarious night.

He wrote, “Was just out with m'girl @ninadobrev & new friend and ND's castmate @wayansjr in ATL. We laughed very little.” Who is this mystery man? He’s actually someone who is mysterious on OUAT, too — David Anders (Dr. Whale)!

Credit: The CW

Considering that David was on a dozen episodes of TVD, it’s no surprise that they’re hanging out. His character, John Gilbert, was Elena’s (Nina) biological dad, and he ultimately gave up his life for her in the Season 2 finale. (Oh, Uncle John. How we loved to hate you.) We’re going to say that these two former co-stars are just friends. However, in real life, they’re actually only eight years apart, so who knows!

Nina’s Let’s Be Cops co-star Damon Wayans, Jr. also added to the conversation, writing, “Too much fun on a Tuesday night. #intimateEiffleTower.” We’re not going to read too much into that one, though we’re hoping that either David makes a cameo in the film or either Damon and/or Nina comes to Once Upon a Time! Too much to ask for? Anything’s possible!

Are you surprised that David and Nina are still friends? Sound off below!