When it comes to swoon-worthy single men on Once Upon a Time, Captain Hook takes the cake. Though he’s done some bad things in his time, he’s charmed his way into our hearts since we first met him in Season 2, and now we’re curious who he’ll end up hooking up with.

It’s no secret that he has chemistry with Emma Swan, but their interactions are usually back-and-forths in a love/hate relationship (emphasis on the latter). They’ve betrayed one another time and time again, yet when they get close on-screen, we always think they’re thisclose to kissing. It hasn’t happened yet, but in due time — perhaps one long night en route to Neverland on the Jolly Roger — it may happen. If you don’t believe us, just check out Captain Swan’s most swoon-worthy moments (in GIFs, no less).

However, Emma isn’t the only one people are pairing Hook up with. Many think that he has chemistry with Regina, whom he refused to help torture when Greg and Tamara had her strapped up and electrocuted. They do often get very close when talking. Hook and Regina also have many parallels. They've both watched their loved ones have hearts ripped from their chest, they've both taken a young boy under their wing (Henry and Baelfire, respectively), and they are both too evil and vengeful for their own good. It’s very possible that they could get together aboard the Jolly Roger, especially if you consider that Emma is still mourning Neal.

Though we’re a bit conflicted about who Hook should end up with — even portrayer Colin O’Donoghue doesn’t know who is right for the captain — we’re sure you have a lot of feelings. Vote in the reaction buttons below for either Captain Swan or Hook Queen, then hit the comments with why he belongs with the lady in question — or propose another option!