Credit: ABC

On Once Upon a Time, The Evil Queen/Regina is known for doing terrible, despicable things, but she’s always been given a second chance. However, after her latest murderous moment — which almost killed Rumplestiltskin, and killed her mother, Cora — everyone is having a hard time forgiving and forgetting.

In a new sneak peek from this Sunday’s episode (Season 2, Episode 20: “The Evil Queen”), it looks like two people may be giving her another chance — but it comes with an ultimatum.

Snow White and Charming are having an intense conversation about the magic beans (which, unbeknownst to them, Regina knows about) and going back to the Enchanted Forest, debating on if they should take Regina.

“Are we really going to leave Regina behind?” Snow questions, to which Charming responds, “She’s too dangerous to take with us.” There are two problems with this: Regina’s wrath and Henry’s inevitable fit about abandoning her.

“Henry won’t like it — he is her mother, despite all the horrors,” Snow tries to reason, leading to some questions from her husband and contemplating giving her another chance.

To that, the level-headed Charming has a reasonable compromise. “Instead of a second chance, let’s give us a choice. Live her days in Rumple’s cell or...” he trails off.

What’s the other option? We’ll have to tune in for the all-new episode on Sunday, April 28, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC to find out! Until then, feel free to watch the clip below on repeat.

Alyse Whitney is an editor at Wetpaint Entertainment. Follow her on Twitter @AlyseWhitney.