Once Upon A Time’s first season ended with a game-changing cliffhanger when Emma (Jennifer Morrison) broke the spell surrounding Storybrooke and all of our fairy tale characters remembered their Enchanted Forest identities. So what can we expect from the Season 2 finale?

Well, it will definitely be a cliffhanger, verified OUAT co-creator Adam Horowitz. As for whether it will be as ballsy as the first season’s remains to be seen. We do know the titles of the two-part season finale: “Second Star to the Right” and “Straight On Til Morning.”

We love a good Peter Pan reference! Though, judging by other clues that have been dropped, this will be more than a passing reference. At their PaleyFest panel, the OUAT cast and crew said they will be visiting another realm this season and we will meet someone new from that realm. Our money is on Neverland. As for the mystery guest, co-creator Edward Kitsis has said we will not meet Peter Pan this season, so our money is on Wendy or Tinkerbell.

What do you think the Season 2 cliffhanger will look like? Will it be as game-changing as the first? Let us know your theories in the comments below!

Catch the next episode of Once Upon a Time on Sunday, March 10, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC.