Credit: ABC Family

On the Pretty Little Liars spectrum of horror, it seems whatever is in Wilden’s trunk ranks somewhere above those creepy dolls from Season 2. This according to PLL showrunner Marlene King, who tweeted as much to a curious fan.

“It’s more disturbing,” she said, sending our speculation into overdrive. We can add this clue to Troian Bellisario’s assertion that, though there was nothing in the actual trunk when they filmed the Season 3 finale, the contents are “pretty awful.” Well, I guess that means we can rule out jelly beans, rainbows, and Ariel’s treasure trove.

Both Marlene and Troian’s vague descriptions make us this the trunk contains a dead body. On other shows, this might narrow down the list of potentials, but it could still be quite a few people on PLL. Among our list of maybe victims: Jason, Cece, Wilden. With the “B” Team in play and our questions about Red Coat growing, it’s hard to guess who might be in the trunk based solely on motive. Luckily, the Season 4 premiere is set to pick up only moments after the Season 3 finale ended. We’ll set a paper bag aside for our resulting panic attack.

Who (or what) do you think is in Wilden’s trunk? Let us know in the comments below!

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, June 11 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.