Credit: Keegan Allen Instagram

Remember way back when in early Season 1, when Spencer spent her days flirting with the cute country club employee rather than masterminding conspiratorial takedowns? Yeah, us either. That’s why we almost didn’t recognize the beautiful, beautiful face of Diego Boneta, who played the aforementioned country clubber (Alex Santiago) and the object of Spence’s affections. So what is Keegan Allen aka Pretty Eyes aka the current keeper of Spencer’s heart doing taking snapshots of Diego?

“My good friend @diegoboneta #monochrom #leica (the only light was from that candle),” Keegan posted along with a gorgeous Instagram shot of his “good friend.” (Honestly, Keegan. It’s like you have no sense of self-preservation. Have you seen the guy with his shirt off?)

Keegan probably doesn’t have anything to worry about. Toby and Spencer will reportedly be going strong when Season 4 starts up, and it doesn’t look like Diego is sticking around for anything other than maybe dinner and some conversation with The Keegs. Diego’s career has flourished since he left PLL. He starred in 90210, Rock of Ages, and Underemployed. He was also named one of US Weekly’s “12 Breakout Stars of 2012.” Way to go, Diego!

Do you miss Alex Santiago? Do you think he should make a reappearance on PLL? Let us know in the comments below!

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, June 11, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.