Credit: ABC Family

The big “A” reveal in Season 3, Episode 12: “The Lady Killer” is one of the biggest twists in Pretty Little Liars history. Toby is “A”?! Did anyone see that coming? Even the cast of PLL was shocked when the second “A” was unmAsked.

In Season 3 DVD special feature, the cast, including Keegan Allen, Lucy Hale, Ashley Benson, and Marlene King herself, react to the shocking reveal. “It was a downpour of sadness,” said Lucy.

Plus, Tyler Blackburn and Lindsey Shaw open up about the scenes they shot in their black hoodies, and for the first time, thanks to this ETonline exclusive, you can watch the unaired clips of Caleb and Paige’s “A” reveals.

In case you didn’t know, the Pretty Little Liars Powers That Be shot three different “A” reveals -- Toby, Caleb, and Paige -- to keep the unmasking a secret. “They left us hanging too,” said Tyler. “It was a little bit unknown as to which direction they were going to go.” Ultimately, Lindsey was “glad” it wasn’t Paige! (We are too. Hasn’t Emily been through enough heartbreak?)

Watch the clip below and tell us: Do you think Caleb or Paige would have been a more shocking reveal?

Pretty Little Liars: The Complete Third Season hits shelves on June 4.