Cece Drake (Vanessa Ray) is a curious character on Pretty Little Liars, as manipulative as she is cool, but has Rosewood’s chattiest resident finally be silenced? Is Cece’s dead body the horrifying something the Liars found in the trunk of Wilden’s police car? Here’s three reasons we think that may be the case.

Last Time We Saw Her...

She was trying to get the hell out of Dodge, er, Rosewood. When Emily came to find her in Season 3, Episode 20: “Hot Water” to ask about Wilden’s connection to Ali, Cece was frantically packing. She had the look of someone scared for her life, and we haven’t seen the girl since. Sure, there’s a chance she’s sipping margaritas on a beach somewhere, but that’s not usually how things work in this town, is it?

Her Wilden Connection

Speaking of Wilden, in the same episode Cece fled, Hanna saw Wilden manhandling the petite blond into his car (foreshadowing?). We’ve never been a fan of Rosewood’s finest, but seeing him resort to physical control moved past creepy and right to downright scary. After Hanna pushed Wilden’s car into a lake, Wilden was desperate to get it back. We’re guessing it wasn’t a double chocolate doughnut he was going back for.

She Knows Too Much

Cece certainly knows a lot about a lot. Even though Ali never mentioned Cece to the Liars, Cece seems to know all of their secrets. She also knows a lot about the summer of Ali’s disappearance. It was Cece who told Emily that Ali was pregnant that summer (a claim that was denied in Ali’s journal, but she would be the type to lie in her own diary). She also has some sort of strange history with Jason. And, she knew Noel Kahn’s older brother. Sometimes, secrets and connections can keep you alive, but in Cece’s case, we think they may have been the very thing that got her killed.

Do you think Cece is in the trunk? Why or why not? Let us know in the comments below!

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, June 11 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.