You probably know Tyler Blackburn (Caleb Rivers) as either Hanna's hunky dark-haired boyfriend on Pretty Little Liars, or as the hunky, dark-haired star of Ravenswood. Whichever show you know him from, the point is you'll think of him as a brunette. But believe it or not, this Johnny Depp lookalike was one blond kid.

The ABC Family favorite posted a childhood photo on his Instagram, writing, "When I was naturally blonde and my mom looked exactly the same as she does now. Yay for hay." Between the mushroom cut and the dirty blond locks, we can hardly tell that's Tyler! He does look like the perfect 90s kid with that haircut, though. Do you think he was inspired by Jonathan Taylor Thomas?

If only Tyler had kept his sun-kissed look, Caleb and Hanna (Ashley Benson) would have been Rosewood's very own Barbie and Ken couple! Hey, we love them anyway.

Want to see the other Pretty Little Liars stars when they were younger? You can check them all here.

Do you even recognize Tyler as a young boy? Let us know in the comments below!

Catch the Pretty Little Liars Season 4 winter premiere on Tuesday, January 7, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.