Credit: Keek

Just when we thought we could fall in love with Keegan Allen (Toby) no further, we heard the man sing. It turns out that not only does the Pretty Little Liars star have the looks and the acting chops, but he also has some serious talent on the guitar. Don’t believe us? Check out his recent Keek, which asks for your opinion on his new lyrics:

“I’m holding you all through the night. You’re the first thing that I see rushing through my dreams because I want you to wake up next to me. Life has almost passed us by and there’s not much left to achieve. Don’t let it slow your pace because what they told you was only what they could believe.”

What do you think? Keep it or heap it? We think the lyrics pretty darn good, especially when sung by Keegan in his sexiest baritone. We can only imagine Pretty Eye’s effect would only be more mesmerizing in person, which is apparently possible to experience given that Keegan will have a set of solo acoustic shows this summer. He mentioned something about Binghamton and Las Vegas in the Keek vid, but we’ll keep you updated!

In the meantime, if you want to hear more of Keegan’s music, check out his cover of Lana Del Ray’s “Born to Die.” Though it might have you asking the same question we are: When is Toby going to serenade Spence on PLL? After what she’s put up with, she deserves a song or two!

What do you think of Keegan’s music? Do you think he should sing in the show? Let us know in the comments below!

Pretty Little Liars Season 4 premieres on Tuesday, June 11, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.