Credit: Video Stills via Hulu

On Pretty Little Liars, we’re constantly envious of the Liars’ clothes and always-flawless hair (even when they are covered in dirt and/or dried blood), but one star doesn’t think everyone always looks amazing.

During a fun “Ask a Liar” Q&A with all of the gals, Troian Bellisario (Spencer) flipped a question on its head. When asked who is the best-dressed character, she explained that it ”totally changes every episode” and that every scene, they compare outfits. “One day, everyone wants Spencer’s outfit, and one day, everyone wants Emily’s,” she dished. “Aria always has a hard time, because we always are kind of looking at her outfit and we’re like, ‘That’s nice... but you look crazy!’”

Oh, poor Aria! She definitely does have an eclectic sense of style, which Janel Parrish (Mona) loves. When asked the same question, she immediately said, “Aria!” Portrayer Lucy Hale said she would be “biased” and say Aria because she doesn’t want wardrobe to be mad, and both Shay Mitchell (Emily) and Ashley Benson (Hanna) said Hanna, though Shay claimed it was a mix of Spencer and Hanna, as she likes both.

But what about the infamous two articles of clothing that “A” loves? Everyone was torn about whether they prefer the red coat or the black hoodie. Again, Troian had the most vocal opinion, explaining, “Since I’ve worn it, I’d say the black hoodie, but the one thing about the hoodie that you don’t realize is that the pants they give you are the most uncomfortable things in the world. I might lean toward the red coat because of the pants.” Uncomfortable pants? No thank you.

For the other four girls, it was split. Janel and Shay prefer the black hoodie (though Shay noted that for Em, it’s hoodie, but she loves the red coat) and Lucy and Ashley went with the bright red number. What about both together? Could be fun...

Are you surprised at their thoughts on PLL fashion? Check out the video, and then hit the comments below!