Shay Mitchell (Emily) has always kept her love life a pretty little secret, but the brunette actress is finally giving us a glimpse into her mystery romance.

The Pretty Little Liars actress took to Instagram yesterday (July 2), posting a photo of a picnic on a sunset-lit beach. She wrote, "Private dinner by the beach cause my baby doesn't play around... #Luckygal." Excuse us while we lift our jaws off the floor.

Shay Mitchell has someone that she's calling her baby? And she's referring to herself as a lucky gal?! This might be more of a mystery than the Wilden storyline.

While we're not sure who Shay could be dating, we do know there were some rumors flying about her and Glee star Jacob Artist earlier in the year. We doubt that's her boyfriend, but hey, we've got to start somewhere as we try and crack this mystery!

Check out the photo below and let us know what you think in the comments.

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, July 2, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.


Credit: Shay Mitchell's Instagram Photo: Shay Mitchell's Romantic Beach Dinner