Keegan Allen has been through quite a rollercoaster in four seasons of Pretty Little Liars, but no matter what happens with his character, Toby Cavanaugh, one thing remains constant: he’s a fan favorite.

This was solidified today when he was nominated for a 2013 Teen Choice Award! Next month, he’ll go up against three fellow ABC Family stars and one Teen Wolf for the coveted surfboard, battling it out for the title of Choice Summer TV Star: Male. He was nominated in this category in 2011, too, but was sadly missed last year. Keegan is definitely ready to make a comeback.

When the awards air live at 8 p.m. ET/PT on Sunday, August 11, he’ll battle it out against The Fosters’ Jake T. Austin, Baby Daddy’s Jean Luc Bilodeau, Twisted’s Avan Jogia, and Teen Wolf’s Tyler Posey. This almost directly aligns with co-star Lucy Hale’s competition — she’s up against all ABC Family female stars for Choice Summer TV Star: Female. Meanwhile, Keegan's on-screen love Troian Bellisario (Spencer), baddie Janel Parrish (Mona), and swoon-worthy pal Ian Harding (Ezra) are nominated for Choice TV Actress: DramaChoice TV Villain, and Choice TV Actor: Drama, respectively.

Oh, and did we mention that PLL is up for Choice Summer TV Show? Better get to voting at TeenChoiceAwards.com — if you’re between the ages of 13 and 19, you can vote once per day until 11:59 p.m. on Saturday, August 10.

Do you think Keegan will win the TCA this year? Sound off below!