Pretty Little Liars Season 4, Episode 11: “Bring Down the Hoe” looks like a big one for Spoby. From the looks of the promo, Spencer (Troian Bellisario) finally had enough lying to the other Liars about Toby’s (Keegan Allen) “A”-led search for the truth about his mother’s death. Will the episode end in a Spoby breakup?!

Normally, we wouldn’t be so worried about the status of Spoby’s relationship they’ve been going strong since the Season 3 finale but PLL writer Maya Goldsmith’s recent tweet has us biting our nails: “Toby will make you guys cry next episode. You will all wish you could reach through your TVs and hug him,” Maya tweeted on August 13.

If our Toby-fueled tears aren’t instigated by a Spoby breakup, then something big will probably go down in Toby’s search for his mother. Our money is on Toby giving up his correspondence with “A” for Spencer. If he wants to stay with Spence, then he has to stop making her choose between the Liars and him. That means telling the Liars about his search, which “A” has made clear will stop her from sending him any more clues about Marion Cavanaugh’s death. At least we hope this is the choice Toby makes. Alliances with “A” never end well, and we don’t want Toby to lose Spencer in the meantime...

Why do you think Toby will make us cry? Do you think Toby and Spencer will break up? Sound off in the comments below!

Source: Maya Goldsmith on Twitter

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, August 20, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.