Pretty Little Liars? More like Pretty Little Singers! The cast of our favorite teen murder mystery is overflowing with talented singers performing in all sorts of style. We love them all — we definitely have a playlist made up entirely of Pretty Little Liars stars' music — but today we're asking a tough question: Of all these talented stars, who's your favorite singer?

It's a hard decision, all right. Everyone's so good, and they perform in so many different styles, from Lucy Hale's country twang to Tyler Blackburn's indie rock crooning. We've gathered some samples together so you can give each voice a listen, and then cast your vote!

Janel Parrish

Janel has a Broadway background, and is a singer-songwriter when she’s not terrorizing the Lias as Mona. Here's her single, "Rainy Day," which she wrote herself.


Lucy Hale

Check out Lucy's country stylings! We can't wait for her album to drop.


Keegan Allen

Keegan Allen is all about that unplugged sound, performing solo acoustic shows. Here he is singing a song he wrote, "Fade Away."


Nia Peeples

Nia has released four albums over her career, and this single, "Street Of Dreams" hit No. 12 on the Billboard Hot 100.


Sasha Pieterse

Like Lucy, Sasha is all about country. Here's her single,  "This Country is Badass."


Tammin Sursok

Tammin was a bona fide Australian pop star before moving to the US to pursue acting. Check out her song "Whatever Will Be."


Troian Bellisario

While Troian doesn't seem to have the same musical aspirations as some of her co-stars, we dig her soulful sound in this rendition of “Skinny Soul” by Aneurysm June.


Tyler Blackburn

Tyler has a smoky voice that works well for rock. Here's his single, "Find a Way."

Who's your favorite Pretty Little Liars singer? Vote in our poll, and sound off in the comments below.

Catch the Pretty Little Liars Season 4 winter premiere on Tuesday, January 7, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET on ABC Family.


Rebecca Martin is an Associate Editor at Wetpaint Entertainment and our resident Game of Thrones, Breaking Bad, and genre TV expert. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!