Credit: Ashley Benson Instagram

Prepare yourself for a Pretty Little Liars cast love fest. Not one, but two of the stars of PLL made it to Keegan Allen’s (Toby Cavanaugh) Off Broadway production of Small Engine Repair over the weekend. Check out the adorable photo of Ashley Benson (Hanna Marin) and Ian Harding (Ezra Fitz) showing their co-star some love and support!

“With this kid @actuallyharding seeing @keeoone in small engine repair,” Ashley Instagrammed yesterday, sharing a snapshot of her gorgeous self and co-star hunk Ian in the audience for the play.

We’re not used to seeing Ash, Ian, and Keegan together too much on screen, but this moment only reaffirms our love for this tight-knit cast! Especially given that Ashley and Ian aren’t the only PLLers who have made it to New York to see Keegs take to the stage.Shay Mitchell (Emily) made it to the play’s opening night in November and was super proud of Keegan: “So so soooooo good! I could not be more proud of @keeoone for doing an AMAZING job in tonight's performance of #smallenginerepair ! A definite must see!!!” Shay posted on Instagram.

Keegan has been making his Off Broadway debut in the critically acclaimed character play since October (which, sorry PLL fans, means a Toby-lite Season 4B). In the play, Keegan plays Chad, a privileged jock who turns up at an out-of-the-way repair shop, stirring much resentment in the three former high schools buddies who frequent the establishment. The production co-stars James Badge Dale, James Ransone, and scriptwriter John Pollono. We’re super proud of Keegan for taking chances in his acting choices, and they’ve seen to paid off!

Catch the Pretty Little Liars Season 4 winter premiere, Tuesday, January 7, 2014 at 8 p.m. ET on ABC Family.