Pretty Little Liarscore four Hanna, Spencer, Aria, and Emily get their pictures taken more than most A-list celebrities. But who’s behind the snapshotting? The show seems to want us to think it’s Ezra who is clicking the pics, but we’re not so sure. Who’s the mysterious photographer?

Paige

It was hard to determine what in Spencer’s head-noir was a clue and what was just her fanciful imagination, but we were mighty suspicious of the photography convo that went down between Paige and Aria. Sure, it could have just been a scene in which Noir Paige needs advice for her cross-country trip with Em, or it could have been a clue that Paige is the one behind all of the Rosewood snapshots.

Lucas

Though we haven’t seen Lucas for a good while, that doesn’t mean he isn’t up to something. When we think of Rosewood photographers, his name is top of the list. He was school photographer before he turned homeschooler. We can’t help think that the more flexible schedule and lack of institutional accountability would make for the perfect creeper photographer.

Ezra

Credit: ABC Family

Just because Ezra’s culpability seems obvious, doesn’t mean it’s not truth. We’ve now seen two of Ezra’s lairs and they are covered in photographs of the Liars. The question is: is he the one taking them or has he farmed the job out to someone else on this list? Conversely, could there be two clandestine paparazzi in this town? That number seems high, even for Rosewood.

Mona

Though Mona seems the type to prefer to have her picture taken, we all know she knows how to work behind-the-scenes without getting noticed. As a former “A” herself, Mona has staged hardcore surveillance on the Liars before. Plus, we know she’s been helping with Ezra with something. Might she have dusted off the old telephoto lens and taken to creeping in Rosewood’s conveniently located hedges? We wouldn’t put it past her. She’s a total mercenary these days.

Who do think has been taking pictures of the Liars? Share your theories in the comments below!

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, February 18, 2014 at 8 p.m. ET on ABC Family.

Kayti Burt is a contributing writer for Wetpaint Entertainment with a penchant for all things pop culture. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!