Credit: Troian Bellisario Instagram Photo: Troian Bellisario Tweets Spoby Photo From Pretty Little Liars Set

Pretty Little Liars mastermind Marlene King is the ultimate Liar in the sense that she knows more Rosewood secrets than anyone else — even “A”! This is probably why she’s such a good tool for Troian Bellisario (Spencer) and Keegan Allen (Toby) to tease all of us fans.

“Storytime with Mar. trust me. You all are so sad you missed out on this one. (Now keegs and I can really be know it alls),” Troian captioned the photo of Keegan looking at Marlene in shock and awe. Is Marlene spilling secrets about future Pretty Little Liars developments?! Do they have to do with Spoby?! Tell us!

You may have guessed by now that we are pretty desperate to get a peek inside the super secret spoiler vault that is Marlene’s brain, especially when it comes to Spoby. Though this two are relatively strong right now compared to some (or, you know, all) other couples on this show, we’re still not sure why Toby jetted off to London to fill Melissa in on Spencer’s condition. Was this really the real reason for his visit? Because we didn’t even know he had a relationship with Melissa. And has he really given up on discovering the truth about his mother’s death?

Basically, we’re suspicious whenever any of the characters takes an extended absence from the Rosewood scene, especially when people are getting shot at on NYC rooftops. Sure, we know Toby’s absence had to do with Keegan’s real-life Off Broadway debut, but that doesn’t quell all suspicions. Was Toby up to something in his absence? And is Marlene telling Keegan and Troian about it in this pic?

What do you think is going down in the photo? Share your theories in the comments below!

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on June 10, 2014 at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.

Kayti Burt is a contributing writer for Wetpaint Entertainment with a penchant for all things pop culture. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!