Clearly, Ali is not above lying these days; in fact, the first thing she did on her return is tell a major lie that involves all of the Liars. But hey, this is Rosewood — no one tells the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.
Being a liar isn't enough to make us condemn someone; the important question is, what's Ali's motive? Is she really just a scared girl doing her best to stay safe in a world that has proved itself anything but, or is she still playing games? Could she even be "A"? Anything is possible...
We're honestly torn, in part because Sasha Pieterse is the master of ambiguous reactions. Take Ali's expression when her mom's body was found. It was hard to tell if she was upset, relieved, happy — or maybe some combo of it all. We're never quite sure what's going on in Ali's brain, which is exactly how she likes it.
The longer Season 5 goes on, the more info we'll get about Ali, but we're curious about where you guys stand right now. Are you on Team Ali, or do you think she might be up to no good?
Vote in our reaction buttons, and sound off in the comments below!
Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars Season on Tuesday, July 1, 2014 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.