Credit: ABC Family

Warning: this article contains spoilers for Pretty Little Liars Season 5, Episode 12 (“Taking This One to the Grave”). Click away now if you don't want to know!

We knew the Pretty Little Liars Season 5, Episode 12 (“Taking This One to the Grave”) was going to feature a big death, so when we saw Toby Cavanaugh (Keegan Allen) get into an epic car crash near the end of the episode with a cut to commercial break we gasped and held our breath. Could the show possible kill off Spencer's (Troian Bellisario) love? Would Toby really be gone for good?


Breathe a sigh of relief, Toby fans: this cop-to-be is a-OK! As we quickly learned after the commercial break, Toby is actually fine, except for a broken leg. Obviously it sucks that he got hurt, especially since he just graduated from cop school, but compared to what happened to the actual victim of the day, this isn't that big a deal. Good. We're not sure Spencer could have taken much else.

Those Pretty Little Liars writers. Very, very tricky. Thank goodness for seatbelts, right guys?

Were you fooled by this fake-out, or were you sure Toby was going to be OK? Let us know in the comments below!