Pretty Little Liars

We’ve spent most of Pretty Little Liars Season 2 convinced that Jenna (Tammin Sursok) and Officer Garrett (Yani Gellman) are working together as “A.” But as the evidence stacked up against them, they slipped lower and lower down our suspect list — despite the fact that they framed the Little Liars for Alison’s (Sasha Pieterse) murder.

So why are we convinced that these peas in a deranged pod aren’t Rosewood’s resident stalker?

1. It’s Too Obvious!
Lately, we can’t get through one episode of Pretty Little Liars without Officer Garrett pulling up in his police car and giving someone the evil eye. Not only do the Little Liars themselves think he’s “A”, but now Caleb (Tyler Blackburn) is completely convinced that he’s evil.

Sure, Garrett and Jenna are likely candidates, but the fact that the show keeps casting them as the usual suspects flies in the face of what we know — the PLL cast members were “shocked” when they learned “A”’s real identity!

2. Garrett Wanted To Quit The NAT Club
Last week, we found out that Garrett intended to quit the NAT club, but Ian (Ryan Merriman) hijacked his plans by blackmailing him. It seems like Garrett is more than a little creepy, but he doesn’t quite have what it takes to systematically stalk four teenagers.

Then again, Jenna holds the reins in this relationship, and we’re pretty sure he’d do anything for her — including polish her snow globe collection and make voodoo dolls.

3. Garrett And Jenna Are Broken Up
If Garrett and Jenna are working together as “A”, they need to be with each other at all times. Jenna went missing for an entire episode, and let’s not forget that girlfriend is blind. How is she going to write loving messages like “Nosey Bitches Die” all over people’s walls without her right-hand man?

Garrett was occupied with finding Jenna while she was gone, and spent a good amount of time banging on her front door during their breakup. So who was manning the surveillance equipment that we assume “A” has set up all around Rosewood? Who managed to rig Toby’s carpentry equipment in such a savvy way? Not a blind girl acting alone...

Sounds like this dynamic duo probably aren’t our favorite serial stalker, but anything is possible in this show! Do you think Garrett and Jenna are “A”?

Catch an all-new Pretty Little Liars on Monday, February 6 at 8pm ET/PT on ABC Family.

Get your Pretty Little Liars fix: Like us on Facebook and Follow us on Twitter and Tumblr!