Credit: AdMedia/WENN.com/Adrianna M. Barraza/WENN.com Photo: Ashley Benson vs. Shay Mitchell

On last night’s episode of It’s a Brad, Brad World, former Rachel Zoe assistant Brad Goreski got the news that he’d been hired to style Pretty Little LiarsShay Mitchell (Emily Fields).

Brad is thrilled, and continues to use Shay's name among his styling credits today. But the Rachel Zoe connection got us thinking: if Brad is styling Shay Mitchell, and his former Rachel Zoe boss Taylor Jacobson is styling PLL star Ashley Benson (Hanna Marin), then who’s doing the prettiest little styling job?

For a direct comparison, we took these two photos of Ash and Shay from the 2011 Teen Choice Awards. Taylor styled Ashley in this gold and black Alice + Olivia dress, and Brad styled Shay in this DKNY silk button-down shirt and shimmering skirt. For accessories, Taylor added a very simple black clutch and equally minimalistic black peep-toe pumps. On Shay, Brad accessorized with a subtly patterned black clutch and, interestingly, minimalistic black peep-toe pumps. Hey, they did both learn from the best, so coincidences are natural.

Who do you think has the best styling: Ash by Taylor, or Shay by Brad?


Catch an all-new Pretty Little Liars on Monday, February 6 at 8pm ET/PT on ABC Family. 

Get your Pretty Little Liars fix: Like us on Facebook and Follow us on Twitter and Tumblr!