Credit: Seventeen Magazine, Teen Vogue Photo: Ashley Benson vs. Shay Mitchell

We’re so proud of the stars of Pretty Little Liars! This month, both Ashley Benson (Hanna) and Shay Mitchell (Emily) landed major magazine covers. Since everything in the land of Rosewood is dramatic, we figured we'd throw the girls in the ring for a photo face-off.

Ashley graced the cover of Seventeen Magazine, rocking denim American-flag shorts, a lightning bolt shirt, and a red blazer. Topping off her summery look are blue highlights in her hair. We're loving her patriotic ensemble!

Shay, on the other hand, looks pretty in pink on the cover of Teen Vogue. Looking stunning as always, she's rocking a pink t-shirt dress, chunky earrings, and a delicate headband. Girly and chic -- just like Shay!

Now for the moment of truth. Take a look at the two pics and let us know which girl really rocked  her cover. Is it Ashley’s fun red, white, and blue ensemble, or Shay’s classic feminine style? Check out the covers, and vote in the reaction buttons below!

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, March 5, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.