full size Pretty Little Liars Season 3 Promo Photoshoot: Shay Mitchell
Credit: Andrew Eccles/ ABC Family

Many of the Pretty Little Liars stars are coupled up in real life, or have had boyfriends recently, but there’s one whose love life is almost as mysterious as the identity of “A.”

Let’s see: Ashley Benson (Hanna) has been on and off with Justin Bieber’s “swag coach” Ryan Good, and Troian Bellisario (Spencer) has her long-term relationship with Suits star Patrick J. Adams. So who is Shay Mitchell (Emily) dating?

Shay has kept her romantic history very hush-hush. She told Seventeen that her high-school boyfriend broke up with her right before the prom, so she wound up going with a big group of girlfriends.

But in an old interview from 5 years ago (Shay says she is 19 at the time; she is 25 now), the reporter asks Shay what her favorite body part is on guys. She replies, “On my boyfriend EVERYTHING, but eyes probably because they are the window to your soul.”

Aside from Shay sparking up some rumors when she was seen in pictures with sexy Glee star Jacob Artist, we think it’s probably a safe bet that Shay is single at this point.
 

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, February 12, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.

Sources: Twitter, Seventeen, DorinhaGirls