Credit: KeeganAllen's Twitter/ Photo: Keegan Allen and Justin Bieber in Beverly Hills on October 23, 2010
He might play a creepy bad boy on Pretty Little Liars, but trust us, Keegan Allen (Toby) is far from that in real life. Off screen he’s a normal guy who is just as excited to see Justin Bieber and play Xbox as the next person.

We’re serious. Keegan stumbled upon Justin Bieber this past Saturday, October 23, and the two started chatting. Can you imagine Toby and JBiebs hanging out? We can’t — but apparently Keegan is a fan. Along with the pic to the left, he tweeted, “Hey, Justin Bieber is a really cool guy!” He then explained to Lucy Hale, “I was just chilling in bev hills and I struck up a convo with him- he is really chill.”

Later that day, Keegan and Diego Boneta, who plays Alex (Spencer’s boyfriend), attended the Kinect for Xbox 360 Launch Party. The two PLL hotties had a ball while Diego showed off his moves. To top things off, Keegs then ran into David Beckham and his boys at the event. Major swoon!