Credit: Twitter

Could Toby really be dead? Or was that just Wilden’s body in disguise? Tuesday night, fans were shocked by Pretty Little Liars latest death, but some aren’t buying it. After all, Spencer never pulled off “Toby’s” helmet, so that could be someone else’s body -- like Detective Wilden’s, perhaps?
 
When Ashley Marin hit Wilden with her car, it looked pretty serious, so we doubt Wilden was able to get up and sneak away from the scene of the crime. And why would he? If he wanted Hanna to keep her mouth shut about his situation with Ali, wouldn’t he blackmail her, using her mom’s freedom as a bargaining chip? Sorry Ashley, but we’re not buying the “Wilden’s OK” story you’re telling yourself. So where is Wilden’s body? Here are a few guesses:

“A” disguised his body as Toby to fool Spencer.  When it comes to scripted TV (especially a show as twisty-turny as Pretty Little Liars), never believe someone to be dead without seeing the face. It seems suspicious that Mona (Janel Parrish) would distract Spencer just as she was trying to take off “Toby’s” helmet. Not to mention his shirt was lifted in just the right spot -- so Spencer could see Toby’s tattoo. We wouldn’t put it past “A” to mark Wilden’s dead body with a fake tattoo.

In the trunk of his police car: This theory is a little more far-fetched, but there was something up with Wilden’s patrol car. And now that it’s most likely going to get fished out of the lake in next week’s episode, we wouldn’t be surprised if “A” left a few clues in the car, most notably Wilden’s body. Not to mention that this would make Hanna (Ashley Benson) and Aria (Lucy Hale) accessories to murder.

What do you think? Where is Wilden’s body? Sound off in the comments!

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, March 5, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.