Credit: Jason Merritt/Getty Images; Jason Kempin/Getty Images Photo: Lucy & Shay: Who Did the Side Bouffant Best?

Two of Pretty Little Liars style stars — Lucy Hale (Aria) and Shay Mitchell (Emily) — have worn a nearly identical hairstyle while making their red carpet rounds in the past year. So who did it best?

In August 2011, Lucy showed up at the Teen Choice Awards with a voluminous side bouffant — her shiny brown hair was curled and swept off to the left, evoking a ‘50s pin-up star look. 

Just a few days ago, Shay showed up at the Badgley Mischka Fall/Winter 2012 fashion show with the same Jessica Rabbit-esque look, only on (gasp!) the other side. 

In all sincerity, they both looked gorgeous, as per usual. But do you prefer Lucy’s looser, wavier style to Shay’s sleeker-than-thou chic twist? Vote in our poll below.


Catch an all-new Pretty Little Liars on Monday, February 20 at 8pm ET/PT on ABC Family.

Get your Pretty Little Liars fix: Like us on Facebook and Follow us on Twitter and Tumblr!