Credit: Eric McCandless/ABC Television Group © 2011 Disney Photo: Huge Spoiler! Lucy Hale Reveals Ezria Will Stay Together

We’re making our list and checking it twice, and now it’s time to find out which Pretty Little Liars are naughty or nice!

Grab your fork, because it’s time to feast on a holiday treat: We’ve rounded up our favorite PLLers and grouped them into two lists — check out which characters are bad to the bone, and which are sweet as pumpkin pie!

Naughty List

Aria Montgomery (Lucy Hale): As much as we love ourselves some feathered hair clips and goth-in-a-sexy-way eye makeup, Aria’s forbidden love affair with Ezra has landed her a spot on the naughty list. Sure, the viewers ‘ship Ezria, but Santa and his elves are old-fashioned.

Spencer Hastings (Troian Bellisario): Spencer shattered our pretty little hearts when she broke up with Toby during the mid-season finale. Of course, her public crying by that giant oak tree sort of made up for it, but then she went and locked lips with Wren. We’re all about a sexy British rebound, but girl: Hit the brakes!

Ezra Fitz (Ian Harding): How many times do we have to ask Ezra to take off those vests and unleash the six-pack within? Hopefully next year he’ll hone the craft of ab-flashing, and while he’s at it, he should probably stop dating teenagers....

Mona Vanderwall (Janel Parrish): We love to hate and hate to love Mona, but her constant snarkitude has nailed her a spot on the naughty list. Mona’s in for a lump of coal in her stocking this year — but don’t worry, we’ll make sure it’s gold-plated.

Alison DiLaurentis (Sasha Pieterse): This girl really needs to figure out whether she’s dead or alive so she can stop haunting Emily’s dirty dreams. Poor Em is confused enough as it is without being macked on by a ghost and left-for-asphyxiated in a shed. Get your act together, Ali!

Jenna Marshall (Tammin Sursok): The pieces of the puzzle are finally coming together, and it looks like Jenna is just as evil as we first thought! Jenna planted Allison’s murder weapon on the Little Liars, an act of deviousness that’s making Santa choke on his cookies in disapproval. 

Lucas Gottesman (Brendan Robinson): Ever since Lucas violated that innocent egg salad sandwich during the Pretty Little LiarsHalloween Special, we haven’t looked at him the same way. Sure, he helped Caleb and Hanna get back together, but we think he’s hiding some tricks up his nerdy sleeves!

Noel Kahn (Brant Daugherty): Noel has yet to redeem himself for being all crazy/sexy (emphasis on the crazy) for the past few seasons. How dare he think of outing Aria and Ezra’s relationship! 

Mike Montgomery (Cody Christian): Mike is still just a kid, and as much as we want him to get his new computer gaming system (or whatever), we just can’t get on board with someone who gets physical with their mom. Especially a mom as sweet and kind as Mrs. Montgomery. You have a lot of apology letters to write in your Moleskine Journal, Mike! 

Melissa Hastings (Torrey DeVitto): We still think Melissa was way too harsh on her little sister, and her stubborn refusal to even try and understand where Spencer was coming from earns her a spot on the Naughty list.

Credit: Photo via abcfamily.com Photo: Maya Moves in Next Door to Emily

Nice List

Hanna Marin (Ashley Benson): We love Hanna so much that we’re going to go ahead and say it: Give this girl all the presents ever! Just lay off the chocolate, Santa. Not everyone wants to look as big and jolly as you.

Emily Fields (Shay Mitchell): Things can get intense in Rosewood, but Emily always manages to keep her cool. She’s sweet, down-to-earth, and never fails to lend her support to her friends. Remember that time she became BFFs with Toby even though he was rocking those terrifying man-bangs? 

Ashley Marin (Laura Leighton): Hanna’s mom has been a voice of reason all season long. Yeah, yeah, she stole thousands of dollars for an old woman, but that was an entire year ago. Let’s get into the holiday spirit and let bygones be bygones!

Maya St. Germain (Bianca Lawson): We don’t know Maya very well (other than the fact that she’s a major pothead), but as far as we can tell she’s as sweet as pie, and only has Emily’s best interests at heart. We can’t wait to see these two kiss under the mistletoe!

Byron Montgomery (Chad Lowe): When Byron first came on the scene, we had him pegged as a lecherous cheater with a heart of stone. But as time’s gone by, Byron’s redeemed himself and now we kind of want him to be our dad. Just saying.

Credit: Eric McCandless/ABC Family Channel © 2011 Disney ABC Television Group Photo: 5. Hanna and Caleb Grow Closer!

Ella Montgomery (Holly Marie Combs): Best. Mom. Ever! Ella can do no wrong as far as we’re concerned. Basically, she’s Rosewood’s equivalent to Mrs. Clause — cheerful, jolly and a good cook. If she turns out to be “A”, there’ll be no reason to celebrate the holidays anymore. 

Wren Kim (Julian Morris): What isn’t there to love about Wren? Other than the fact that he’s definitely “the other man” in the saga of Spoby — but we’ll overlook that in favor of some yuletide cheer. 

Toby Cavanaugh (Keegan Allen): This wayward teen definitely deserves the Boyfriend Of The Year Award. He’s frighteningly devoted to Spencer, to the point where we’re worried he might go bat crazy and kill someone if he thinks they’re hurting her. After all, he probably learned all sorts of Murder 101 skills from Jenna!

Caleb Rivers (Tyler Blackburn): Swoon! Caleb and his long, free-flowing hair had us from the moment he strolled onto campus and started peddling cell phones. We’ve never had a reason to distrust him, he loves Hanna with all his heart, and he looks good next to a roaring fire. His very existence is a Christmakkah miracle!  

Jason DiLaurentis (Drew Van Acker): You might think that Jason belongs on the naughty list, but aside from developing creepy photos of Aria “Sleeping Beauty” Montgomery, he has a heart of gold! Jason might get up to no good next season, but here at Wetpaint, we follow the creed “innocent until proven guilty.”

Want more Wetpaint Entertainment? For all the latest on Pretty Little Liars, "like" us on our Facebook page at facebook.com/PrettyLittleLiarsFansite, or follow us on Twitter at twitter.com/PLLWetpaint.