Credit: Video Still

When Pretty Little Liars announced its spin-off Ravenswood, we were ecstatic. Double the teen drama, double the fun, right? However, when Marlene King revealed that someone would be leaving Rosewood for this mysterious new town (and show), our bodies weren’t ready. And then when we found out that it was the one and only Tyler Blackburn (aka Caleb), we had so many feelings.

To properly express them, we’ve rounded up the Pretty Little Liars’ reactions — or at least how we’d imagine them — in GIFs! Scroll down to see our five stages of feels, and then hit the comments with your own!

1. Shock.

 photo shockedclues_zps6c50d02e.gif

2. Yay for Tyler!

 photo tumblr_m8x1e1qLL41rxgnvao1_500_zpsea336873.gif

3. What about Haleb?! NOOOOOOOO!

 photo haleb_zps043fb9d4.gif

4. Poor Hanna!

 photo dontcry_zps05293356.gif

5. Conflicted Feels

 photo cantdeal_zps704f8f70.gif

P.S. Don’t forget — Ravenswood is right next door to Rosewood and...

 photo trip_zps3d6121b9.gif
Alyse Whitney is an editor at Wetpaint Entertainment. Follow her on Twitter @AlyseWhitney.