We never got a good look at the dead body Spencer (Troian Bellisario) found in the Rosewood forest in Season 3, Episode 21: “Out of Sight, Out of Mind.” Mona (Janel Parrish) wanted Spence  to believe it was Toby (Keegan Allen), but weren’t so sure. Now it appears as though the body belonged to a park ranger, but what about the other body Emily’s mom refers to in the promo for Season 3, Episode 23: “I’m Your Puppet”?  Whose body is that? Here are a few of our best guesses:  

Toby
Ok, so we’re hoping the body wasn’t actually Toby’s (not only due to our Spoby love, but because PLL is usually wilier than that), but there is always a chance it was. We’ve seen neither hide nor hair of Rosewood’s fittest carpenter since Spence discovered he was an “A” teamer. Perhaps his love for Spencer made him a liability? We’re not really sure what “A” team retirement entails, but we’re guessing it looks something like that scene in the woods.

Cece
We’ve never been sure whose side Cece (Vanessa Ray) is on, but she was seriously freaked out when she fled town in Season 3, Episode 20: “Hot Water.” She is seen arguing with Wilden and then later Emily finds her frantically packing, eager to get out of Rosewood. Did Cece ever make it out of Rosewood? And could she be connected to whatever Wilden seems so desperate to retrieve from his submerged car?

Jason
We’re seriously worried about Jason (Drew Van Acker). He narrowly escaped a murder attempt in a runaway elevator car, only to disappear from his hospital bed a few hours later. Perhaps whoever tried to take him out the first time returned to finish the job. Jason seems to be searching for Ali’s killer as eagerly as the Liars. Was he finally stopped? Have the Dilaurentises lost another child?

Who do you think Spencer found in the woods that night? Let us know in the comments below!

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, March 12, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.