Credit: ABC Family/ Wetpaint Entertainment

Update 2/22:
 
Our top pick came from Cassie Clifford, who said:
 
Dianne: I need to speak to you.
Aria: Me? Why me? Can't you go bother someone else?
Dianne: I really don't see why I should...everybody else here looks poor and utterly tasteless.
Aria: I probably shouldn't tell you this, but if we're being completely honest, blue isn't your color, and I may or may not be hooking up with both of your sons.
 
As you can see, we've decided to up the ante, and from now on will turn the winning captions into a fun graphic!

 

It’s time for another Pretty Little Liars Caption This contest! Last week we asked you to tell us what was going on between Emily (Shay Mitchell) and Jason (Drew Van Acker). Our top pick came from Jada Williams, who said:

Emily: Jason, I need to talk to you.
Jason: What about?
Emily: About Mona. What's going on between you two?
Jason: Uhhh....she's my....half-sister too!

That's about as convincing as the explanation he gave during the episode!

This week, we want you to come up with your funniest caption for this photo from Season 3, Episode 20: "Hot Water," where Aria (Lucy Hale) talks to Ms. Fitzgerald.

Leave your best captions in the comments below, and come back next Friday (February 22) to find out who the winner is!
 
Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, February 19, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.