Rejoice, Spoby fans! Toby (Keegan Allen) isn't dead. He's alive and well — but can we trust him?
In the Season 3 finale of Pretty Little Liars (Episode 24: "A dAngerous gAme"), Toby told Spencer (Troian Bellisario) the only reason he joined the “A” team was to protect her. But do we really believe him?
Spencer sure does! She tried to give him the cold shoulder — after all, he did break her heart — but in the end, she couldn't resist him. Do we really blame her? One look into Toby's sad, puppy dog eyes, and we'd be all over him too! While Spoby's reunion was heartfelt and intimate — Lana Del Rey really set the mood — we can't help but feel like there's something he's not telling Spencer.
Why couldn't he be a double agent? Spencer confessed her "A" status to the Liars and still managed to pretend to be faithful to the "A" team. If he wanted to protect Spencer, then why did he break her heart?
Of course, we have a soft spot for Spoby, so we want to believe Toby is telling the truth. In the end, he did get knocked out for trying to help the Liars. Unless, "A" was trying to pass him a clue with that lighter/compass.
What do you think? Can we trust Toby? Are you happy Spoby has been reunited? Sound off in the comments!