Looks like things are going to get worse before they get better for Rosewood residents (would we really want it any other way?). Shay Mitchell (Emily) told Glam “one of the characters in Rosewood could possibly be getting removed from Rosewood by the A team.” Yikes! Here’s our three guesses as to who it could be.

1. Toby (Keegan Allen). Toby’s fate has been up in the air ever since a heartbroken Spencer discovered he was playing for Team A in Season 3, Episode 16: “Misery Loves Company.” Not to mention the fact that fellow Team A-er Mona doesn’t seem to have his best interests at heart. The other shoe on Toby’s betrayal has yet to drop as Spencer hasn’t told the other girls about it, but without anyone to watch his back, Toby would make an easy scapegoat for Team A to cut loose.

2. Paige (Lindsey Shaw) and Caleb (Tyler Blackburn). We’re putting them into one category because, if something happens to either one of them, it will be for the same reason: for their well-intentioned stealth attack against Team A in the name of the ones they love (Emily and Hanna, respectively). We’re not exactly sure what they’re up to, but their assumption that just because they are not one of the main four means that they’re not being watched is a dangerous one. A sees all!

3. Hanna (Ashley Benson). Sure, up until now A has kept the girls from being permanently damaged (unless you count long-lasting psychological trauma), but that could change at any time. Hanna moved up the list of potential targets after the extra-creepy epilogue at the end of Season 3, Episode 17: “Out of the Frying Pan, Into the Inferno” in which someone took a blowtorch to the side of doll-Hanna’s head.

Even if Hanna doesn’t get permanently removed from Rosewood, things seem to be getting pretty tense between her and her mother after last week’s episode when she was arrested for underage drinking. And, let’s be honest, these girls are pretty much always one disaster away from being shipped off by their parents to some boarding school in Vermont.

Which of Rosewood’s residents do you think could be the next to go? Sound off in the comments below!

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, February 5, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.