Credit: ABC Family

Pretty Little Liars showrunner Marlene King reportedly described the contents of Wilden’s trunk as “pretty close to your worst nightmare,” and Troian Bellisario (Spencer) corroborated. The horrifying contents of the trunk will be revealed in the Season 4 premiere. Here are our best guesses at who or what it could be.

Who

We still think there’s a good chance that the Liars find a body in Wilden’s trunk. The question is: whose body might it be? We’ve rambled on about the possibility of Jason or Cece being the unlucky Rosewoodians, but given the recent spoilers about Hanna needing “a rock” in Season 4, we’d like to add someone else to the list: Ashley Marin. She went to “New York” for the last few episodes of the season and Ella had trouble getting a hold of her, which makes us worry about Hanna’s feisty mom. Another spoiler-influenced guess is Wilden. We know that two state police officers are joining the cast of characters in Season 4. The death of a local police officer might warrant state interest, and their addition makes a lot more sense if Wilden is out of the picture.

What

We’ve been assuming that someone’s dead body is inside of the trunk because, really, what could be more horrifying? But what if it is something? In the Season 4 promo, we hear one of the Liars saying, “She set us up.” Could something in the trunk incriminate the girls’ of wrongdoing? Perhaps some sort of gruesome evidence linking the Liars to Ali’s disappearance or to Garrett’s murder? PLL also has a knack for spooky imagery, especially when it comes to masks and dolls. We know that there will be a maskmaker character in Season 4, and that dolls will play a part in the premiere. Could the contents of the trunk be another homage to creepiness a la the doll shop?

Who or what do you think is in Wilden’s trunk? Let us know in the comments below!

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, June 11 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.