Credit: Ron Tom/ABC Television Group © 2012 Disney Photo: Aria and Duncan Talk on Pretty Little Liars Season 2, Episode 23

Just when we thought we’d figured out the motives and intentions of Holden (Shane Coffey) on Pretty Little Liars — fight club? — we find out that another hottie will be coming to Rosewood and confusing us even more.

As we reported last fall, Australian actor Lachlan Buchanan was cast in the recurring role of Duncan, a new character that will appear towards the end of Season 2 in at least two episodes. And now we have a photograph from Season 2, Episode 23: “Eye of the Beholder.”

All we can really tell from the image is that Aria (Lucy Hale) will be talking to him, for some reason, on the patio outside Rosewood High School. We know from the episode synopsis that Duncan is someone from Alison’s (Sasha Pieterse) past.

Is it possible that Duncan is the voice on the phone from Season 2, Episode 19: “The Naked Truth”? Or is he someone we’ve never heard about or seen before?

Catch an all-new Pretty Little Liars on Monday, February 13 at 8pm ET/PT on ABC Family.