As if these two could not get any cuter, Shay Mitchell uploaded a new Keek video of her and fellow Pretty Little Liars star Ashley Benson having a sing-along in the car during their lunch break! Looking chic in black sunglasses, both girls rock out as R&B stars Monica and Brandy, respectively, in their lip-synched rendition of “The Boy Is Mine.”

We have to say that this reminds us of Ashley’s infamous parody video of Justin Bieber’s song, “Boyfriend” that she did with James Franco, only a lot less weird. Who doesn’t love to sing along to their favorite songs in the car, especially when you’ve got a BFF to sing along with you?

Watch the video of Ashley and Shay below, then tell us what you think of their “performance” skills in the comments!