It's no surprise that gorgeous, smart, and fiercely independent Spencer (Troian Bellisario) has hordes of cute boys drooling over her on Pretty Little Liars. But which guy would be best for our Little Liar?

Until recently, we were 110 percent on board with Spencer/Toby (Keegan Allen). Spencer's other prominent love interest, Wren (Julian Morris), is undeniably a cutie, but Spencer and Toby had an open and honest bond that seemed hard to beat. Too bad it was also too good to be true.

Now that we know Toby is on the "A" team, we're no longer sure who Spencer should be with. We still haven't given up on Spoby — we're holding out hope that Toby's feelings for Spence were real, even if he was also busy messing with her — but they're facing a big obstacle, to put it mildly.

Enter Andrew, the hot academic decathlon member who told Spence to "put on your Hastings face, and spank [Mona] tomorrow like I know you can" on Season 3, Episode 15: "Mona-Mania!." Um, perfect for Spencer, much? Of course, this is Rosewood, so while Andrew seems like a sweetie based on what we saw of him, he very well could turn out to be super sketch. Sigh.

And let's not forgot Wren! Now that Toby seems like less of a perfect boyfriend, Rosewood's hottest doc is suddenly an appealing option, even if he is a bit old to date a high schooler (that didn't stop Ezria!).

However, as much as we love listening to Wren talk, is he just spinning a web of lies? PLL executive producer Oliver Goldstick recently warned Zap2it that Wren's "a snake."  

"Anyone who functions in Rosewood on this show, and is that handsome, be afraid,” he teased. Um, but can’t the same be said for all of the guys on PLL?

We want to know what you think: Do you ship Spoby, Wrencer, or Spandrew? Or do you think Spencer would be better off single for a while? Vote in our poll, and sound off in the comments below!

Find more Pretty Little Liars spoilers here.

Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Tuesday, January 22, 2013 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC Family.