We know that you’re dying to know who “A” might be! Don’t worry — we’ve got our crack team of sleuths on the case, picking up even the tiniest clues for your mystery-solving pleasure. Here are the hints from “If At First You Don’t Succeed, Lie, Lie Again” that may help us solve this thing for good!

Suspect #1: Caleb
Why he might be “A”: This guy is so sneaky that it’s easy to believe he could be “A.” He has a way of making things happen, like when he screwed with Ella’s car to prevent her from reaching Philly in time. And for some reason, Caleb knows more about car repair than Jay Leno.

Why he might not be “A”: He was actually pretty helpful this week. In fact, the only real argument he had with Hanna was over Justin Bieber. And if finding Bieber to be a little annoying were a crime, then an awful lot of us would be behind bars. Plus, Caleb is new to Rosewood and it just wouldn't make sense for him to be "A" but only start showing his face now.

Suspect #2: Paige McCullers
Why she might be “A”: New character Paige obviously knows a lot about Emily’s love life, not to mention that she bought bracelets that were identical to the kind that Ali once bought. That lady who runs the bead store apparently has quite the monopoly on bracelets in this town!

Why she might not be “A”: Sure, she was pretty upset that Emily was supplanting her on the swim team, but we’re not sure that frustration about the swim team is enough reason to think someone might be “A.” Then again, we’re not exactly experts on competitive swimming. (Translation: Forget the pool — we prefer the hot tub!) Also, she has the new kid in town thing going on, just like Caleb.

Suspect #3: Jason DiLaurentis
Why he might be “A”: Jason has always been a nuisance, but he reached creepy new heights while spying on the girls at the end of the episode. We wish he would spend less time lurking in the shadows and more time taking his shirt off.

Why he might not be “A”: He is obviously distraught over his sister’s disappearance and wants to know what happened to her. Spying on the girls was weird, but when you've got four hot girls hanging out together in the next house over with the window open and lights on, it's kinda hard not to stare...

Want to speculate more about who "A" really is? Check out our Who Is "A" page for more scoop!