Suspect #1: Jenna Marshall
Why she might be “A”: Jenna Marshall (Tammin Sursok) definitely had a part to play in Alison (Sasha Pieterse)’s death — why else would she care so much that the little liars are suspicious about what really happened to Ali? We know you can’t see this for yourself, Jenna, but things aren’t looking good for you and your collection of snow globes.
Why she might not be “A”: “A” watches every breath the little liars take (Sting, much?), but Jenna is often clueless when it comes to the whereabouts of the gang of mean girls who blinded her. She didn’t even know that Aria (Lucy Hale) was taking a pottery class at Hollis! Plus, does “A” really seem like the type to have sex next to an open window?
Suspect #2: Aria Montgomery
Why she might be “A”: We’ve already devoted an entire article to why Aria is on our “A” list, but now there’s even more evidence against her! It looks like page 5 of Ali’s autopsy file disappeared while it was in Aria, Spencer (Troian Bellisario) and Emily (Shay Mitchell)’s care, which means one of them may have taken it! Aria booked it out of the hospital without Spence and Em, and we never really saw where she went after meeting up with Ezra (Ian Harding)... Did she go back down to the morgue, hide under a sheet, and binge eat Oreos?
Why she might not be “A”: C’mon: look at that face. Girlfriend wouldn’t hurt a fly! Unfortunately the same can’t be said for exotic birds with pretty feathers....
Suspect #3: Wren Kim
Why he might be “A”: It’s quite the coincidence that Wren (Julian Morris) nabbed a job at Rosewood Hospital just as the little liars started solving Ali’s murder. Is he trying to keep tabs on them? We’re betting that the huge plant Wren brought Spencer has a hidden camera in it. We don’t care how sexy this bloke’s English accent is, facts are facts: He’s an adult male who spends way too much time hanging out with teenage girls.
Why he might not be “A”: A sexy Englishman doesn’t just walk into a hospital and get residency without doing something to deserve it, which means Wren had to have been attending school this entire time. It’s the perfect alibi!