Pretty Little Liars: Ashley Benson & Shay Mitchell Covergirl Face-Off

Two of our favorite Pretty Little Liars are April 2013 covergirls! Ashley Benson graced the cover of Seventeen magazine in a fun, summery ensemble -- complete with a lightening bolt t-shirt, American flag denim shorts and a bright red blazer. Meanwhile, Shay Mitchell looked lovely on the cover of Teen Vogue. Shay kept it classy in a soft pink dress, chic accessories and a subtle, stylish 'do. 

Aside from just looking adorable, Ashley spilled some juicy information to Seventeen. Not only did she dish on Shay Mitchell looking for a boyfriend, but she revealed that Justin Bieber was not happy when she made a "Boyfriend" parody video with James Franco. Meanwhile, Shay opened up to Teen Vogue about playing a lesbian on PLL.

So which cover do you prefer? Are you more like laid-back Ash or super stylish Shay? Vote in the reaction buttons below!