Which Pretty Little Liars Star Is Older: Shay Mitchell or Lindsey Shaw? 1 of 2 Previous Autoplay Next Share Tweet November 16, 2012 at 02:42PM EST by Molly Friedman Related: Pretty Little Liars, Shay Mitchell, TV Stars, Lindsey Shaw full size Credit: Getty Images Which Pretty Little Liars Star Is Older: Shay Mitchell or Lindsey Shaw? Even though Shay Mitchell (Emily) and Lindsey Shaw (Paige McCullers) both play 17-year-old high schoolers on Pretty Little Liars, both ladies are really in their 20s. But can you guess which actress is older? We’ll give you a hint: one of them is surprisingly two years older than the other!